Optimal foraging theory and the psychology of learning1 oxford. The situations to which optimal foraging theory has been applied, with the exception of a few recent studies, can be divided into the following four categories. Fishermens strategies differ depending on their intended prey. They spend more time in patches and use fewer patches for shrimp than for fish. Optimal foraging theory attempts to explain the foraging patterns observed in animals, including their choice of particular food items and foraging locations. Optimal foraging theory 527 words, according to this view, the effort to develop this theory is hopeless because one or more of the basic assumptions is almost certain to be false. Investigating optimal foraging theory in the laboratory. Optimal foraging theory states that animals should maximize resource acquisition rates with respect to energy expenditure, which may involve alteration of strategies in response to changes in. In this sense, it is hypothesized that animals forage optimally. Recent applications of models of optimal foraging behavior to human foraging economies are summarized and evaluated. The marginal value theorem eric charnov follow this and additional works at. Several facets of it have been examined empirically using operant conditioning with varied schedules of reinforcement and degrees of reward.
Optimal foraging theory was first proposed by robert macarthur, j m emlen, and eric pianka in 1966. The development of optimization theory has made important contributions to the study of animal behavior. The optimal foraging theory states that animals will do the least amount of work to gain the greatest amount of resources. Although obtaining food provides the animal with energy, searching for and capturing the food require both energy and time. The optimal foraging approach has also grown enormously in terms of numbers of publications and it continues to grow see figure 2. In this study, predictions from optimal foraging theory patch model, in particular of patch residence time, are compared to the observed behavior of fishermen on fishing trips. Optimal foraging theory parker major reference works. Optimal foraging and learning 233 elapsed on a patch being rit. If the reader doubts that this was a real factor, he or she should read the article by pierce and ollason 1987 entitled eight reasons why optimal foraging theory is a complete waste of time. Optimal foraging theory explains adaptation via natural selection through quan titative models. This seminar, which extended over two academic quarters, produced the basic finegrained foraging models and some hints about wider applications of the results. We assume that, for each i, rit is a strictly decreasing function which tends to zero as t tends to oo. Optimal foraging theory is a set of concepts and models that aim to explain the wide variation in foraging strategies among individuals and between species, guided by the assumption that living things are designed by a history of natural selection.
Although different in detail, the papers were collectively unique in their proposal that prey selectivity could be understood as driven by a tendency, selected through evolution, to maximize net energy gained per unit time. But the optimization approach needs to be integrated. Behaviors that are most likely to be favored by natural selection. Optimal foraging theory predicts that animals will either attempt to maximize energy gained or minimize time spent to obtain a fixed amount of energy. Optimal foraging ecology began in 1966 with the backtoback publication in american naturalist of two papers, one by macarthur and pianka, the other by emlen.
Optimal foraging theory is a principle that is often presented in the community ecology section of biology textbooks, but also can be demonstrated in the laboratory. In its most basic form, optimal foraging theory states that organisms forage in such a way as to maximize. We introduce a lab activity that uses an interactive strategy to teach high school andor college students about this ecological concept. Effects of food type and patch location on foraging. Sensing opprobrium from their colleagues, scientists evidently began to shy away from identifying with optimal foraging theory. This study sheds a light on economic roots of optimal foraging and optimal mating theory. Optimal foraging illustrates the organisms forage in such a way as to maximize their net energy intake per unit time. Pdf assumptions behind optimal foraging theory are.
This approach to animal foraging behavior began to develop about 1 8 years ago with papers by. Optimal foraging theory oft is a model that helps predict how an animal behaves when its searching for food. The travel time between patches, r, is a random variable with a finite expectation o foraging. These experiments can be used alone or in combination and can also provide a foundation for students to. Optimal foraging theory and western gray squirrels 3 optimal foraging theory and western gray squirrels sciurus griseus griseus all animals need food and an intake of energy in order to survive. Optimal foraging theory a central concern of ecology has traditionally been foraging behavior. This book had its genesis in a rather disorganized and poorly conceived lecture on optimal.
These models predict patterns of prey choice, habitat use, time allocation, settlement pattern, and foraging group size that will maximize some objective currency such as the net rate of energy capture while foraging under the constraints of resource characteristics and. Brief history of optimal foraging theory animal behaviour. When organisms have limited access to energy, natural selection is likely to favor individuals within a population that are more effective at acquiring energy. Optimal foraging theory has become an important part of behavioral ecology since 1966, when emlen and macarthur and pianka first developed mathematical models for ideal time allocation by a foraging organism. Science in forestry, fisheries, and wildlife, university of washington, seattle, washington 98195. Optimal foraging theory has at its heart the postulate that foragers maximize their net rates of energy intake while foraging p. Pyke, in encyclopedia of animal behavior second edition, 2019.
Optimal foraging theory is one of several costbenefit analysis used to predict or explain animal behavior. Optimal foraging by birds the american biology teacher. Such time includes both searching for prey and handling i. Optimal foraging theory and western gray squirrels. Optimal foraging, the marginal value theorem eric l. Optimal foraging for multiple resources in several food species. The first assumption of the optimal foraging theory is natural selection will only favour behaviour that maximizes energy return. Optimal foraging theory oft is a behavioral ecology model that helps predict how an animal behaves when searching for food.
Optimal foraging theory oft is a behavioral ecology model that helps predict how an animal. All animals do this, whether its squirrels, lions, or even humans. Optimal foraging theory predicts that animals will behave in such a manner as to maximize their energy intake benefit with the minimal output of energy cost. As a result of these similarities, the models have become known as optimal foraging models. A timeminimizing approach implies that an animal is attempting to maximize time spent in other behaviors such as reproduction or to minimize its exposure to temperature extremes, predators, or. Optimal foraging theory has only been sporadically applied to nonhuman primates. We describe three experiments designed to test hypotheses about food choice and foraging habitat preference using bird feeders. The classical prey model, modified for patch choice, predicts a sliding profitability threshold for dropping patch types from the diet, preference for profitable foods, dietary niche breadth reduction as encounter rates increase, and that exploitation of a patch type is unrelated to its own abundance. Beginning in the mid1960s, the annual number of publications considering foraging theory grew exponentially, especially during the late 1970s. Foraging, which is the process by which animals obtain food, is a fundamental activity for animals, as they require food to sustain their metabolism, provide energy for a wide range of activities, and support reproduction. Optimal foraging theory predicts that a foraging organism will maximize its fitness by maximizing. Abstract abstract the literature on effects of habitat fragmentation on biodiversity is huge. Allocation of energy to growth or reproduction reduces the amount of energy available to other functions, such as defense.
The deficiencies in that treatment, combined with the obvious potential of an improved conceptual. Optimal foraging theory oft is an approach to the study of foraging behavior that uses the techniques of mathematical optimization to make predictions about this critical aspect of animal behavior pyke, 2010. Foraging, which is the process by which animals obtain food, is a fundamental activity for animals, as they. Eight reasons why optimal foraging theory is a complete waste of time pdf. Two examples show graphical optimisation models of behavioural ecology that are identical. Foraging by bees provides an area where optimal foraging can be tested.
Anthropological applications of optimal foraging theory. For some species, foraging can be extremely costly in terms of. Pianka, stating that natural selection favours animals whose behavioural strategies maximize their net energy intake per unit time spent foraging. Costbenefit analysis to generate predictions regarding behavior. In its simplest form, optimal foraging theory predicts that animals in search of food. Part of thebiology commons this article is brought to you for free and open access by the scholarly communication departments at unm. Optimal foraging theory explains how animals make foraging decisions based on the availability, nutritional content, and handling times of different food types. Optimal foraging theory oft background, problems and possibilities mesolithic cave on the island of stora karlso, gotland, sweden. Issues raised in anthropological critiques of optimal foraging theory are also discussed, including 1 the models degree of realism, 2 the validity of neodarwinian assumptions and simple energeticefficiency currencies, 3 the need to incorporate the effects of risk and uncertainty, and 4 the relation of individual decisionmaking to processes occuring at larger spatial and temporal scales. A brief history of optimal foraging ecology springerlink. Pdf optimal search behavior and classic foraging theory.
1438 1607 915 540 160 891 1565 584 79 1581 253 1565 908 251 1493 1056 53 1162 1511 943 733 738 1622 195 242 1175 852 103 1345 1491 669 347